What's new

Minnesota under siege

  • Context: Civil Rights 
  • Thread starter Thread starter Borg
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary
SUMMARY

The forum discussion centers on the ongoing protests in Minnesota and the invocation of the Insurrection Act by federal authorities. Minnesota Governor Tim Walz has mobilized the National Guard in response to escalating tensions. The conversation draws parallels to Canada's Emergency Measures Act invoked by Prime Minister Justin Trudeau during the Truckers Convoy protests in 2022, highlighting issues of governmental overreach and the suppression of civil rights. The discussion also references the tragic shooting of Renee Good by an ICE agent, raising concerns about law enforcement's role and accountability in these situations.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of the Insurrection Act and its implications for state and federal authority.
  • Familiarity with the Emergency Measures Act in Canada and its historical context.
  • Knowledge of civil rights and the legal frameworks governing protests in the U.S. and Canada.
  • Awareness of the role of federal agencies like ICE in law enforcement and immigration issues.
NEXT STEPS
  • Research the legal ramifications of the Insurrection Act and its historical applications.
  • Examine the Emergency Measures Act and its impact on civil liberties during protests in Canada.
  • Study the role of law enforcement agencies in managing protests and their accountability mechanisms.
  • Investigate the implications of federal versus state authority in crisis situations, particularly in the U.S.
USEFUL FOR

This discussion is beneficial for political analysts, civil rights advocates, law enforcement professionals, and anyone interested in the dynamics of governmental authority during civil unrest.

For sure.

I guess that I shouldn't be surprised that the NRA is defending the victim. I expect that the vast majority of them are MAGA-leaning but this hits them in their precious 2nd Amendment that they defend at any cost. They probably don't like having to defend Alex Pretti but it won't look good for them in court if they selectively defend gun owners. My bet is that they don't put up much of a complaint beyond this.
 
If this is what they do to law abiding US citizen healthcare workers with valid conceal carry permits who aren't posing a threat, while they are being video taped, imagine what the non-citizens they disappear to their prison camps must be getting.
 
There's a leaked video on the /r/law subreddit showing conditions inside one of the concentration camps in Baltimore.

USA! USA!
 
And these are the consequences for the things you say and the things you believe.



“When someone chooses to listen to a politician, a so-called journalist, or a community leader that spouts that type of vilification towards law enforcement or anything else… there are consequences and actions there also, I think we saw that yesterday.”

AAAAAAND THE HOOOOOOOME OF THE BRAAAAAAAVE
 
Full analysis of the shooting. It appears that they had full possession of Pretti's gun when the shooting started. DHS also hasn't said if his gun was ever fired.
 
@fresh_42 Here is an example of what I described earlier as 'theater' that gets an occasional mention but isn't covered much since there is no way to make it happen. I consider NBC news to be mainstream media, not left media, for the record, so my assertion that mainstream media doesn't give these soundbites oxygen stands somewhat adjusted / corrected.

In my view, until political consequences can be be made real (a necessary condition for legal consequences I think) we are a morally bankrupt society. I am not noting the below as anything more than information.

 
There are 3000 ICIE and CBP officers in Minneapolis, more than the police in the city and the surrounding suburbs. There are an estimated 130,000 illegals in Minnesota. Florida, a Republican state, has an estimated illegal population of between 700,000 and 1M but it only has a couple of hundred ICE agents in the state, although state law requires the cooperation of local police to help. The CBP officers are inappropriately being used in Minneapolis. They are not trained in immigration law or in crowd control. No doubt Trump wants a confrontation and a reaction from the citizens to use the Insurrection Act.

One final note, an ICE agent in Maine was said to have told a person taking video that they were being identified as a domestic terrorist and entered into a national database.
 
Remember this photo from Michigan April 11, 2020, as protestors stormed the state house.

1769468058098.webp

With Trump posting: “The Governor of Michigan should give a little, and put out the fire. These are very good people,”
 
The CBP officers are inappropriately being used in Minneapolis. They are not trained in immigration law or in crowd control.
A common mistake is interpreting what's happening through the lens of what we expect from a normal, law-abiding administration. The lack of appropriate training is irrelevant because they're not really there to enforce immigration law. George Conway explains it better than I can:

 
I was in the kitchen. The news was on TV in the living room, and I was half-listening. It took half a minute, and only when the announcer used the word Iran, did I realize that the report wasn't about Minneapolis at all.

Strange new world.
 
@fresh_42 Here is another example of pushback coming from the ICE homicides, although this one is getting quite a bit of attention and you may have heard about it in Germany.


Some background on Senate rules and how it relates to minority party ability to impede -

In the Senate, measures that are related to mandatory spending can pass under what is called reconciliation, which only requires 50% of the Senate, and in this congress Dems cannot block a reconciliation measure.

ICE funding is discretionary, not mandatory by law, so the Senate R's cannot use the reconciliation process to pass it. It needs 60 Senators to pass it, so Dems can (and say they will) block it.

In general, if I ever wonder why Senate Dems are or are not blocking something, I start by asking the internet if its a reconciliation measure, and that often gives me the answer.
 
I guess that I shouldn't be surprised that the NRA is defending the victim. I expect that the vast majority of them are MAGA-leaning but this hits them in their precious 2nd Amendment that they defend at any cost. They probably don't like having to defend Alex Pretti but it won't look good for them in court if they selectively defend gun owners. My bet is that they don't put up much of a complaint beyond this.
I've seen that Fox News are now siding with the victim too. I guess that is because they are more beholden to the NRA than to Trump and MAGA.
Depends where the money is coming from I guess.
 
I've seen that Fox News are now siding with the victim too. I guess that is because they are more beholden to the NRA than to Trump and MAGA.
Depends where the money is coming from I guess.
I think it's more that even Trump has bowed to the public's reaction to the execution by replacing Noem with Homan and removing Bovino. Few people are buying the lame arguments trying to justify the killing. As shameless as the people on Fox are, I wouldn't be surprised if even they were embarrassed trying to side with the administration,
 
I wouldn't be surprised if even they were embarrassed trying to side with the administration

I do hope this is correct. Maybe he can't actually shoot someone in broad daylight and get away with it after all. I wonder if he is regretting that those words became such a prominent part of his brand.
 
I think it's more that even Trump has bowed to the public's reaction to the execution by replacing Noem with Homan and removing Bovino. Few people are buying the lame arguments trying to justify the killing. As shameless as the people on Fox are, I wouldn't be surprised if even they were embarrassed trying to side with the administration,
I doubt embarrassment, shame, integrity, consistency mean anything to these guys.

Fox, Trump, Republicans and MAGA have played up the Epstien files, and gun rights for years.
The USA conservatives turned on a dime over Russia, international trade, State's rights vs Federal overreach, but they are not turning on Epstein files, nor on gun rights.
Well the armchair critics are turning on gun rights, they are proclaiming the issue to be the victims' fault, "they shouldn't have been there, shouldn't go to protests with guns (Rittenhouse anyone?), should do as the authorities tell them (Jan 6 anyone?)"

But Fox News is siding with the victim because no doubt the NRA are putting pressure on them. The guy was a permit holding carry holder, has every NRA fought right to peacefully carry a gun.
I'm damn sure the NRA are putting much pressure onto anyone they donate money to, to take up their side in this.
 

Liberal Democracy Values

  • Free and Fair Elections
  • Rule of Law
  • Separation of Powers & Checks and Balances
  • Protection of Civil Liberties and Human Rights
  • Pluralism & Political Competition
  • Independent Media & Free Press
  • Open Civil Society

Community Values

  • Civility
  • Productivity
  • Good Faith Debate
  • Evidence Based Debate
  • Transparency
  • Integrity

Community Motto

"It is the responsibility of intellectuals to speak the truth and expose lies." - Noam Chomsky
Back
Top