I couldn't come up with the perfect title for this thread so I settled for what it is. Other contenders were -
What is wrong with the Democratic party?
Why did the Democrats lose the election?
What is the most important lesson for Democrats post-election?
Anyway, I am interested in discussion of what Democrats need to do differently in order to win back both houses of congress and the White House.
I expect some disagreement, and I hope that those who disagree with me will engage in discussion.
I'll try to get the ball rolling with a couple thoughts.
The Democrats need to be more than the conservative opposition party that is fighting MAGA change to our nation. "We are not going back" was fine, but insufficient. We needed a lot more around how we are moving forward and to where. I believe I know what Trump's vision for America is. I don't know what any individual democrats vision of America is, and I don't believe the Democratic party as a whole has a clear vision for America. This was a huge handicap for Harris imo. So, we need a vision. If this thread ends up being a debate about whether or not there already is a vision, or what that vision is, I think that would support my claim that there really isn't one. If it turns out I'm the only one who doesn't see the clear Democratic vision, I'll acknowledge it.
Democrats are terrible at winning divisive politics. Republicans are better at it. We need to use our inclusive muscles and find a way to agree with MAGA on outcomes and strongly differentiate on means to get there in order to get some more voters in the tent.
I'll give two examples that I think would have helped the Dems in the last election, had they done it. You may strongly disagree with my examples and still agree with my general argument, of course.
The US was at record oil production levels during the Biden administration. This should have been repeated by Biden every single week, he should have taken credit for it. I think he didn't because Trump was saying "Drill baby drill". There is a tacit recognition that we won't transition to renewables without a lot of fossil fuel harvesting in the meantime, that should be made explicit by Democrats.
Another example - Harris and Biden should have been saying for four years that our border security is not where is should be and here is what we are doing about it. Instead, Democrats really downplayed the issue for two years, not appreciating how much it mattered to centrist voters. When Sinema and Lankford worked out the border bill, Trump had so completely owned the border issue that all he had to was say "no, this issue is mine, don't let the Dems get any credit for it, they are late to the party and don't really mean what they say" and democrats had insufficient credibility on the issue to force a vote on the bill. If its hard to find a border message that progressives can live with, well, politics is hard, figure it out. Ignoring the issue was not a winning strategy, that is clear in hindsight.
We put a lot of energy into analyzing Trumps atrocious policies - I hope we can also put some into getting our own house in better order.
Non-democrats are also welcome on this thread, btw - don't mean to imply otherwise.
What is wrong with the Democratic party?
Why did the Democrats lose the election?
What is the most important lesson for Democrats post-election?
Anyway, I am interested in discussion of what Democrats need to do differently in order to win back both houses of congress and the White House.
I expect some disagreement, and I hope that those who disagree with me will engage in discussion.
I'll try to get the ball rolling with a couple thoughts.
The Democrats need to be more than the conservative opposition party that is fighting MAGA change to our nation. "We are not going back" was fine, but insufficient. We needed a lot more around how we are moving forward and to where. I believe I know what Trump's vision for America is. I don't know what any individual democrats vision of America is, and I don't believe the Democratic party as a whole has a clear vision for America. This was a huge handicap for Harris imo. So, we need a vision. If this thread ends up being a debate about whether or not there already is a vision, or what that vision is, I think that would support my claim that there really isn't one. If it turns out I'm the only one who doesn't see the clear Democratic vision, I'll acknowledge it.
Democrats are terrible at winning divisive politics. Republicans are better at it. We need to use our inclusive muscles and find a way to agree with MAGA on outcomes and strongly differentiate on means to get there in order to get some more voters in the tent.
I'll give two examples that I think would have helped the Dems in the last election, had they done it. You may strongly disagree with my examples and still agree with my general argument, of course.
The US was at record oil production levels during the Biden administration. This should have been repeated by Biden every single week, he should have taken credit for it. I think he didn't because Trump was saying "Drill baby drill". There is a tacit recognition that we won't transition to renewables without a lot of fossil fuel harvesting in the meantime, that should be made explicit by Democrats.
Another example - Harris and Biden should have been saying for four years that our border security is not where is should be and here is what we are doing about it. Instead, Democrats really downplayed the issue for two years, not appreciating how much it mattered to centrist voters. When Sinema and Lankford worked out the border bill, Trump had so completely owned the border issue that all he had to was say "no, this issue is mine, don't let the Dems get any credit for it, they are late to the party and don't really mean what they say" and democrats had insufficient credibility on the issue to force a vote on the bill. If its hard to find a border message that progressives can live with, well, politics is hard, figure it out. Ignoring the issue was not a winning strategy, that is clear in hindsight.
We put a lot of energy into analyzing Trumps atrocious policies - I hope we can also put some into getting our own house in better order.
Non-democrats are also welcome on this thread, btw - don't mean to imply otherwise.
